When it comes to choosing a new countertop, one question often comes up more than any other:
Should I choose quartz or granite? What’s better?
In my opinion both materials are beautiful, durable, and can add value to your home, but they aren’t the same. The right choice depends on your personal preference, lifestyle, budget, and the look you’re trying to achieve.
As someone who has worked in Alberta’s countertop industry, I’ve seen homeowners struggle with this decision. This blog will break down the pros and cons of each material to help you make an informed choice.
What Is Quartz?
Quartz countertops are engineered stone made from natural quartz crystals combined with resins and pigments. This creates a durable, non-porous surface that offers consistent colour and pattern through every slab.
Pros of Quartz
- Non-porous and highly stain resistant
- Doesn’t require sealing
- Easy to clean with soap and water
- Wide variety of colours and patterns
- Consistent appearance throughout the slab
Cons of Quartz
- Can be more expensive depending on the brand & colour
- Stubborn stains (some stains will not come out with only soap and water, will require other cleaning products)
- Not recommended for prolonged exposure to high heat—always use trivets or hot pads
- Durable, yet will still chip if hit with force
- Less natural variation than granite
What Is Granite?
Granite is a natural stone cut directly from the earth (quarries). Every slab is unique, with its own colours, movement, and character. There are granite and natural stone quarries all over the world.
Pros of Granite
- Completely unique appearance in each slab
- Excellent heat resistance
- Extremely durable
- Can increase the value and appeal of your home
Cons of Granite
- Requires periodic sealing to maintain stain resistance
- Colour and pattern vary from slab to slab
- Some lighter stones may be more susceptible to staining if not properly maintained
- Can also chip if hit with force
Quartz vs. Granite Comparison
Maintenance
Winner: Quartz
Quartz requires very little maintenance. Since it’s non-porous, it doesn’t need sealing and resists most everyday stains.
Granite should be sealed periodically, although many modern sealers last for years with proper care.
Durability
Tie
Both materials are excellent choices for busy households.
Granite offers superior heat resistance, while quartz excels at resisting stains and requires less ongoing maintenance.
Appearance
Winner: Personal Preference
Choose granite if you love the beauty and uniqueness of natural stone. Usually slabs are have busier patterns, offering rich colours.
Choose quartz if you prefer a cleaner, more consistent, modern appearance. Most quartz slabs have plain or white bases making them ideal for the minimalist homeowner.
Cost
In Alberta, both quartz and granite come in a wide range of price points depending on the brand, colour, slab availability, edge profile, thickness and installation requirements.
Many homeowners are surprised to learn that premium granite can cost as much or even more than high-end quartz. Rather than focusing solely on material type, it’s best to compare complete quotes for the specific products you’re considering.
Which Is Better for Alberta Homes?
There isn’t a single “best” choice. For most busy families, I often recommend quartz because it’s easy to maintain, highly durable, and performs well for everyday cooking and entertaining. For those doing home flips, or rental properties I think quartz is the best for a lower investment.
Granite is an excellent option for homeowners who appreciate the uniqueness of natural stone and don’t mind the occasional maintenance that comes with it. Those that are renovating or building their dream home, I would definitely reccomend granite over quartz.
Granite is an excellent option for homeowners who appreciate the uniqueness of natural stone and don’t mind the occasional maintenance that comes with it. Those that are renovating or building their dream home, I would definitely reccomend granite over quartz.
My Recommendation
If you:
- Have young children
- Cook frequently
- Want minimal maintenance
- Prefer a modern, consistent look
Quartz is likely the better choice.
If you:
- Love natural materials
- Want every countertop to be one of a kind
- Enjoy timeless design
- Don’t mind sealing the surface when needed
Granite may be the perfect fit.
Final Thoughts
Choosing new countertops is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make during a kitchen renovation. Both quartz and granite are excellent investments that can provide decades of beauty and performance when professionally fabricated and installed.
The best choice is the one that fits your lifestyle, your home’s design, and your long term goals, not simply the one that’s trending.
If you’re still unsure, visit a local showroom and view full slabs in person. Seeing the colours, patterns, and finishes firsthand can make the decision much easier, and will give you the idea of the big picture.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does quartz crack easily?
No. Quartz is extremely durable under normal household use, though like any stone surface, a heavy impact on an edge or corner can cause damage. Or if cabinets are not leveled, stress can cause cracks in the stone.
Can I place hot pots directly on quartz?
It’s best not to. Sudden temperature changes can damage the resin that binds quartz together. Always use a trivet or hot pad.
Does granite stain?
Granite is naturally porous, so it can stain if spills are left sitting for extended periods. Applying a quality sealer helps protect the surface.
Which countertop adds more value to a home?
Both quartz and granite are considered premium countertop materials and can enhance the appeal and value of a well-designed kitchen.
Leave a Reply